Do-it-yourself Bagels Recipe | The Recipe Critic

This web site could comprise affiliate hyperlinks and promoting in order that we are able to present recipes to you. Learn my privacy policy.

These home made Bagels are the proper texture, chewy, dense, but delicate, and oh so scrumptious! Higher than store-bought each time, these home made bagels are approach simpler than you assume!

Ah, Bread, it’s important to adore it, and it’s so a lot simpler to make home made than you assume. It’s important to attempt these and my different favorites, you gained’t remorse it, Bread, Challah, and English Muffins.

Homemade bagels with one sliced with cream cheese.

Bagel Recipe

There may be probably nothing higher than bagels which might be home made. These style nearly precisely just like the genuine New York-style bagels. Do-it-yourself bagels are chewy and delicate inside, with a crispy exterior, and go completely with schmear! Schmear is only a fancy phrase for a pleasant slather of cream cheese, however it’s enjoyable to say. Chances are you’ll by no means purchase store-bought bagels once more, particularly after you see how straightforward these are to make.

Just like making pretzels, you’ll boil the bagels earlier than baking them. It will give them the traditional chewy texture and sheen that’s infamous with contemporary made bagels. it additionally helps the bagels maintain their form whereas baking. Bagels originated in Poland within the 1400’s and had been delivered to America by Jewish immigrants. It’s mentioned that by the 1900’s there have been greater than 70 bagel outlets simply within the Decrease East Facet of Manhattan alone. Now you can also make them within the consolation of our own residence. If you can also make dough and boil water, you can also make bagels. Let’s do that!

What You Will Want To Make Do-it-yourself Bagels

  • Heat water: That is to dissolve the yeast.
  • Immediate yeast: Each prompt and dry lively will work nice on this recipe.
  • Sugar: That is to assist feed the yeast, so it’ll bloom.
  • Salt: Provides taste to the dough, don’t skip it.
  • Oil: Provides moisture and taste.
  • All-purpose flour: You too can use bread flour for bagels.
  • Water:That is for boiling the bagels.
  • Honey: Add the honey to the boiling water.

How To Make The Greatest Bagels

  1. Yeast: Combine heat water (100-105 levels), yeast, and sugar collectively within the mixing bowl of a stand mixer. Put aside and permit to get frothy for about 5 minutes.
  2. Mix: Add salt, oil, and flour to the yeast combination. Utilizing the dough hook, combine on low velocity for about 6 minutes till the dough is easy. It ought to spring again in the event you press it along with your finger and mustn’t tear while you pull it. If it leaves an indent or tears when pulled, knead for a pair extra minutes. As soon as it’s prepared, place in an oiled bowl and canopy with plastic wrap or a clear damp dish towel to rise for 1 ½ hour or till doubled in measurement.
  3. Form: As soon as doubled in measurement, punch the dough down and switch it out onto the counter. Divide into 8 equal sections and kind them into balls. Utilizing your thumb, press it via the middle of the ball and stretch it out to kind the bagel ring. Chances are you’ll really feel such as you’re stretching it out an excessive amount of, however the bagels will show bigger as they’re boiled and baked, so the middle of the ring must be bigger than you need it after all of the baking is alleged and accomplished. Set the rings apart to relaxation for quarter-hour.
  4. Prep: Preheat the oven to 425.
  5. Boil: Convey water and honey to a boil. Being cautious to not overcrowd the pot, because the bagels will develop as they boil, boil the bagels for 1 minute on all sides. After eradicating from the boiling liquid, add any desired toppings whereas the dough remains to be cheesy.
  6. Bake: Bake for 25 minutes. Cool fully.
  7. Get pleasure from: Toast if desired and serve along with your favourite toppings.
Making and proving the bread dough.

Baking Ideas for Bagels

There are recipes on the market that take as much as 2 days, however you may get the identical outcomes utilizing this fast and simple recipe.

  • Flour: All-purpose flour works high quality with this recipe. If you need even chewier bagels, use bread flour. They may style the identical however the bread flour will make it chewier.
  • Water for yeast: Use water that’s between 105 and 115 levels to activate your yeast. If it’s too sizzling or too chilly your yeast gained’t develop.
  • Yeast: Each lively and prompt yeast work fantastically with this dough. I like activating the yeast earlier than including the components as a result of I can inform if it’s good or not. In case your water is an efficient temperature, however your yeast isn’t effervescent it’s most likely gone unhealthy. Get new yeast and begin once more.
  • Boil: Boiling the bagels will give it the traditional chewy shiny exterior we now have all come to like in a bagel. Including the honey helps it brown and crisp. You’ll be able to omit the honey in order for you or substitute it for brown sugar. Don’t over crowd the water when boiling and preserve the water at a low boil, not a tough boil to assist keep away from wrinkles in your bagels.
  • Parchment or Oiled Pan: The very last thing you need is your lovely bagels to stay to the pan. Use parchment paper or a well-oiled pan to bake them.
  • Toppings: You do not want an egg wash to get your toppings to stay. As quickly as you’re taking the bagels out, they are going to be cheesy, good for toppings to stay.

Cutting, shaping, boiling and baking the dough.

Shaping Into Circles

With regards to shaping their isn’t a unsuitable approach actually, so long as they’ve that traditional gap within the center. I’ll provide you with two methods right here.

  • Roll it lengthy: One strategy to form bagels is to roll the sections into a protracted rope, not too skinny and never too thick. Take the ends and overlap them barely and roll forwards and backwards to kind a bond. This offers that traditional bagel look the place one finish of the bagel is thicker and one is thinner.
  • Roll it right into a ball: That is the strategy I used and discover it to be the simplest. Roll the sections of dough into good uniformly formed balls. Along with your thumb push via the dough until you meet your index finger on the opposite aspect. Pull and stretch the bagel form until you may have a big gap. It would rise and shut each while you let it relaxation and boil it, so it’s alright to have a big gap.

Bagels with different types of toppings on them.

Easy methods to Retailer Baked Bagels

If these don’t disappear in minutes, retailer them to eat later.

  • Retailer: Preserve leftover bagels at room temperature tightly sealed in a plastic bag for as much as 4 days, or within the fridge for 7 days. Toast them when able to eat.
  • Freezer: Tightly wrap the bagels individually and place them in a freezer-safe bag. Freeze for as much as 3 months. Allow them to thaw at room temperature, toast, and high as desired.

Up close picture of two bagels with poppy seed and everything seasoning.

Bagel Variations

Apart from the traditional Everything seasoning and poppyseeds, you may get artistic and high your bagels in many alternative methods. In addition to add flavors to the dough to combine up the flavors.

  • Cheese: Add asiago, cheddar, or different cheese of option to the dough while you add the flour. Prime the bagel with shredded cheese earlier than baking.
  • Cinnamon and Sugar: Add a teaspoon of cinnamon to the flour after which make up a cinnamon and sugar topping so as to add earlier than to the bagel earlier than baking.
  • Salt: Use coarse salt to high the bagel. Regulate to your liking.
  • Seeds: Apart from poppyseeds, you should use sesame seeds and even sunflower seeds to high your bagel. I like so as to add sunflower seeds to the dough as nicely.

Holding a homemade seasoned bagel with a bite out of it.


  • Combine heat water (100-105 levels), yeast and sugar collectively within the mixing bowl of a stand mixer. Put aside and permit to get frothy, about 5 minutes.
  • Add salt, oil, and flour to the yeast combination. Utilizing the dough hook, combine on low velocity for about 6 minutes till the dough is easy. It ought to spring again in the event you press it along with your finger and mustn’t tear while you pull it. If it leaves an indent or tears when pulled, knead for a pair extra minutes. As soon as it’s prepared, place in an oiled bowl and canopy with plastic wrap or a clear damp dish towel to rise for 1 ½ hours or till doubled in measurement.
  • As soon as doubled in measurement, punch the dough down and end up onto the counter. Divide into 8 equal sections and kind them into balls. Utilizing your thumb, press it via the middle of the ball and stretch it out to kind the bagel ring. Chances are you’ll really feel such as you’re stretching it out an excessive amount of, however the bagels will proof bigger as they’re boiled and baked, so the middle of the ring must be bigger than you need it after all of the baking is alleged and accomplished. Set the rings apart to relaxation for quarter-hour.

  • Preheat the oven to 425.

  • Convey water and honey to boil. Being cautious to not over crowd the pot, because the bagels will develop as they boil, boil the bagels for 1 minute on all sides. After eradicating from the boiling liquid, add any desired toppings whereas the dough remains to be cheesy.

  • Bake for 25 minutes. Cool fully.

  • Toast if desired and serve along with your favourite toppings.


the proofing course of could be sped up by inserting the bowl of dough lined with a clear damp dish towel in a heat oven set at 150 levels. It needs to be doubled in measurement in about 1 hour.
As an alternative of honey you might use 2 tablespoons of barley malt syrup or 1 tsp of baking soda within the boiling liquid.

Serves: 8

Energy321kcal (16%)Carbohydrates68g (23%)Protein7g (14%)Fats2g (3%)Saturated Fats1g (5%)Trans Fats1gSodium301mg (13%)Potassium83mg (2%)Fiber2g (8%)Sugar21g (23%)Vitamin C1mg (1%)Calcium16mg (2%)Iron3mg (17%)

All dietary info relies on third get together calculations and is simply an estimate. Every recipe and dietary worth will differ relying on the manufacturers you utilize, measuring strategies and portion sizes per family.

Course Bread, Breakfast

Delicacies American

Key phrase bagel recipe, bagels, home made bagels

Leave a Reply